ComicTropes
ComicTropes's Channel
 
 
Vince Colletta: The Inker Who Ruined Jack Kirby's Art
13,333
How Marvel Comics' Editors Ruined Hobgoblin
6,266
The Worst New Superhero Costumes of the 90s
5,633
Tracing the Success of Greg Land
5,186
Did DC's New 52 Fail?
5,000
Comic Book Ads / Scams
4,873
The Worst X-Men Run
4,460
Jim Shooter: From Comics Superstar to Outcast
3,740
 
Comic Tropes Extra
List Type Episodes
Horror
Holiday Stuff
Image Comics
 
Vince Colletta: The Inker Who Ruined Jack Kirby's Art
13,333
How Marvel Comics' Editors Ruined Hobgoblin
6,266
The Worst New Superhero Costumes of the 90s
5,633
Tracing the Success of Greg Land
5,186
Did DC's New 52 Fail?
5,000
Comic Book Ads / Scams
4,873
The Worst X-Men Run
4,460
Jim Shooter: From Comics Superstar to Outcast
3,740
The Insanity of Neal Adams' Batman Odyssey
3,666
How Marvel's Editors Botched the Spider-Man Clone Saga
3,386
Johnny the Homicidal Maniac: What's it actually About?
3,113
Why Steve Ditko Quit
3,106
Venom is a Goofball
3,086
The Controversies of Cerebus' Dave Sim
3,053
Howard Chaykin: The King of Controversial Comics?
2,593
How The Walking Dead Comic NAILED Its Ending
2,486
Stan Lee's Worst Ideas
2,453
The Highs and Lows of Tom King's Batman Run
1,806
Watchmen's Exquisite Corpse: Doomsday Clock
1,806
 
Comic Tropes Extra
List Type Episodes
Horror
Holiday Stuff
Image Comics
Global Comics
Creator Analysis
DC Comics
Indie
Marvel
Storytime
Manga
Funny Older Comics
Inktober 2019
Inktober 2018
Livestreams
Animation
Inktober 2017
Toybox Trivia
 
ComicTropes
Your channel viewers will see links here, including "subscribe" and "add as friend".
Profile
 
Name
ComicTropes
Description
Analysis of comics, both good and bad. Primarily I look at the recurring elements that creators or characters use. It's all just an excuse to drill down on various techniques and comic book history.
Subscribers
275K
Subscriptions
Recent Activity  
ComicTropes Hey all! I will have a fully edited video ready tomorrow. I broke my ankle and sitting at my desk to edit becomes painful so I have to take breaks to ease the swelling. The short version is it takes more time to edit than I estimated but I’m confident I can finish today and share tomorrow! Thanks for your patience. Releasing tomorrow instead of today will probably confuse the algorithm here a bit so any likes or shares when you see the show will be appreciated! (3 weeks ago)
 
 
ComicTropes Over on my second channel, I’m reviewing the movie Guyver, based on the manga. (2 months ago)
 
 
ComicTropes I will have a new episode tomorrow but today I encourage you to watch this one. It’s me and Dave doing a deep dive into Daniel Warren Johnson’s Absolute Batman story. (2 months ago)
 
 
ComicTropes I made an hour long video that’s up today but it’s on the WestCoastDAVEngers channel. You’ll see it if you’re subscribed here, because it’s a collaboration. We break down Daniel Warren Johnson’s art and storytelling decisions for Do a Powerbomb! (3 months ago)
 
 
Channel Comments
Budgetdisco (6 years ago)
Coletta’s rage quit letter should be analyzed in high school AP English classes. Glorious
ColdFuse96 (6 years ago)
He didn't fire him because he didn't want to take away another man's income.
Wellies_Yay (6 years ago (edited))
What I got from this:
sh-guitar (6 years ago)
He meeting his deadlines probably kept a lot of important issues from being cancelled
DragonaxFilms (3 years ago)
"Jesus had one Judas, Jim had several"
binglebangle230 (6 years ago)
It sounds like this guy was a product of the industry, and not really bad by himself.
ju4444n (6 years ago)
Too bad he didn't become a writer instead. That letter was epic!
JohnCena-ew1mf (4 years ago)
That letter to the Marvel editors was epic. Kudos to Coletta for sticking up for his friend, even if it unfortunatley cost him his career.
Norvo82 (6 years ago (edited))
By the early 80s, George Perez famously refused to let Colletta touch his work. He went on record, calling Vinnie a "great equalizer". He lifts or brings down every artist to his level, no matter the penciller, it all ended up looking like Colletta.
Rometiklan (6 years ago)
Love that scathing letter Colletta wrote. Maybe he missed his calling. He was a writer in an inker's body.
napstadragon (1 year ago)
17:20 the line "Jesus had one Judas ... Jim had many" goes SO hard omg this letter is fantastic
paulthoresen8241 (6 years ago)
He wasn't even bad, just not amazing. If this work is him rushing and cutting corners then he still had talent.
yinoveryang4246 (6 years ago)
Seems Colleta missed his vocation. Should've been a writer, not an artist.
LegacyCrono (6 years ago)
The part that fascinates me is how Kirby not only kept working with him but also started to play to Colletta's strengths, even to explore new ways of doing background in a way that would benefit his inking. What an amazing guy.
yeloid6747 (6 years ago)
"Colleta had loyalty."
jacobstaten2366 (6 years ago)
"We need to get rid of him."